Hello dear
Welcome to Horseman bagels
At Horseman Bagels, the passion for crafting the perfect bagel shines through every bite. Located in Sleepy Hollow, NY, this charming spot offers a delightful selection of fresh, airy bagels that are crisp on the outside and light on the inside. From unique flavors like pumpernickel and rosemary-garlic to classic cream cheese spreads, every option caters to a variety of tastes. Customers rave about the quality and freshness, with many returning for the exceptional bacon, egg, and cheese bagels. With a warm ambiance and friendly service, Horseman Bagels is more than just a eatery; it's a community haven for bagel lovers.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bakers Dozen Bagels
Bagel with Lox
Chopped Cheese Sandwich
Tuna Salad
About
Horseman bagels
Welcome to the delightful world of Horseman Bagels, nestled in the charming town of Sleepy Hollow, NY. Located at 276a N Broadway, this quaint bagel shop has been making waves with its freshly baked bagels and friendly service. With an inviting aroma wafting through the air, Horseman Bagels is a must-visit for both locals and visitors seeking a satisfying meal or quick snack.
What sets Horseman Bagels apart is their commitment to quality and flavor. The bagels, priced at $2.25 each, are known for their incredibly light and airy texture. Reviewers rave about how these bagels, when toasted lightly, provide a crisp bite that doesn’t weigh heavily on the stomach. If you’re someone who loves a hearty breakfast without the extra dough, Horseman’s offerings will fit the bill perfectly.
The variety here is also commendable. With unique flavors like pumpernickel and rosemary sea salt, these bagels offer a twist on the traditional. As one customer noted, “The best pumpernickel bagels around!” It’s clear that they’ve made a name for themselves in the bagel game.
Beyond the classic bagels, Horseman offers a range of tempting options. From a bagel loaded with lox for $13.50 to sumptuous breakfast sandwiches like the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese for $7.75, there’s something for everyone. The bagels can be paired with various flavored cream cheeses, including vegetable and scallion at just $5.50.
- Bagel with Cream Cheese: $4.75
- Bagel with Egg and Cheese: $7.00
- Bakers Dozen Bagels: $16.99
- Chopped Cheese Sandwich: $9.99
- Coffee: $3.00 – a perfect partner for your bagel!
Not just for bagel lovers, Horseman Bagels also presents a selection of sandwiches and sides, like the Pancakes for $7.99 and various salads priced between $8.75 and $9.25. This diverse menu makes it a standout spot for breakfast or lunch, with options suitable for all appetites.
Compliments also come in for the cozy setting shared with a Carvel ice cream shop. The location offers convenience, along with ample parking, making it an easy stop for anyone in the area. The welcoming demeanor of the staff—"friendly and efficient" as one customer put it—adds to the charm of visiting Horseman Bagels.
In summary, Horseman Bagels not only serves delicious, freshly baked bagels but has also cultivated a warm environment that beckons you to walk through the door. Whether you’re in for a quick bagel and coffee to start your day or looking to savor unique flavors that might tickle your palate, Horseman Bagels is sure to leave a lasting impression. So, if you haven't already, make your way to Sleepy Hollow and indulge in a bagel experience that is, quite simply, delightful!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I stopped by Horseman Bagels to pick up a Too Good To Go order. The very nice man handed me two big bags of bagels. Wow! They share space with a Carvel there and everything was very clean. Now, these bagels toast up very light. This bagel will not lay heavy in the tummy. You get an airy, crisp bite if you toast lightly. Different from my usual type but flavorful and great if you want a light bagel without scooping out all the dough. I don't do this, but for those that do, I think you will find it's so light you might not need to. They had a nice pumpernickel bagel and rosemary sea salt bagel. You don't find those everywhere! ”
“ Great stop for a bagel and coffee. The bagels are so fresh and the cream cheese options are decent. Said is friendly and serves you with a smile and efficiency! Eggs everything and pumpernickel everything bagels recommended ”
“ The best pumpernickel bagels around! And the rosemary-garlic are amazing!! Worth going out of the way for these!! ”
“ Been an active TooGoodToGo user recently and love trying new spots! Though this bagel place has been open for a minute, was glad to pick up a bag that I was able to store in my freezer (tip: slice your bagels before storing!) These bagels are fairly large, they almost didn't fit in my bagel cutter! Not really a fan of the rainbow bagels but all the other flavors were perfect! Definitely will be back, especially to pick up a schmear! ”
“ Carvel and horseman bagel is in one building. They have parking behind the place as well if there is none in the front. They have no restroom. The ice cream cakes that they had were soo nice. I would have bought the hello kitty one but it would have melted with our 2 hrs ride back home. We ordered the garlic bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese. They ran out of the rosemarie garlic bagel which I wanted to try. It was crowded when we went. ”
“ I found this restaurant on my Too Good To Go app. I decided to try it out because I like bagels and I like sandwiches. I went one morning after work. I wanted to see what the hype was about. The entrance it pretty confusing if you don't live in Sleepy Hollow. This restaurant "appears" to be next door to the Carvel Ice Cream Shop. You actually have to enter through the Carvel Ice Cream Shop. I was immediately greeted and given time to think about what I wanted to order. I grabbed a Snapple Fruit Punch from the open fridge. I ordered an Egg and Cheese on a Bagel. I requested my plain bagel be toasted with butter and then spread with grape jelly before topping with the egg and cheese. I must say the sandwich was good (not like I make my egg and cheese bagels at home). The bagel was toasted a little too much to my liking, so the bottom was hard to bite and the cheese was not mixed into the egg. My sandwich was wrapped in aluminum foil and placed into a bag. They had no napkins available at the time (which is crazy because they had been open for almost two hours before I arrived). There's not much seating inside, but they also have some seating outside. (Which is nice for a sunny day or when the weather is good). Not too many inside, so it was nice and quiet when I placed my order. Will try again and next time ask that my bagel not be toasted too much. I spent like $8.50 for the bagel sandwich and drink. ”
“ Back again for bagels now they are re-open. Carvel also carrys many ice cream cake options. They currently offer gift certificates for any one interested in gifting local treats. Sayeed helped me today and is friendly and warm and happens to be one of the owners. ”
